Nope. I was talking BOTH - though admittedly that's unusual. There's more to a shaft profile, these days, than just kick point. 'Tip' and other attributes certainly have a bearing on flight.
As I said, it seems more love or hate than most shafts. It may be a shaft that really suits a particular swing type and doesn't suit others! So worth trying first rather than just taking a punt - and that price seems 'full'.
